Discord ticket bot vs modmail
Modmail runs support through DMs with a bot. A ticket bot opens a private channel from a panel in your server. How they differ, and which one fits your server.
Pick modmail if one team handles one kind of request, such as reports about other members. Pick a ticket bot if different requests go to different people, or you want forms and saved transcripts.
How modmail works
A member sends the bot a direct message. The bot opens a thread or channel that only staff can see, and passes every reply back to the member's DMs. The member never leaves their DMs and has no channel to find. Some modmail bots can also hide which staff member replied.
How a ticket bot works
A ticket bot posts a panel in one of your channels: a message with a button or dropdown option for each category, the kinds of request you take, such as Support, Billing or Appeals. A member picks one, and the bot opens a private channel that only they and that category's staff can see.
Each category has its own staff roles, questions and messages, so billing tickets reach the people who handle billing. Staff can bring someone else in with /add, and when the ticket is done, the conversation is saved as a transcript.
Side by side
| Modmail | Ticket bot | |
|---|---|---|
| Starts with | A DM to the bot | A panel in your server |
| What the member sees | Only their DMs | A private channel |
| Sorting requests | Staff read and route each one | The member picks a category |
| Details up front | Asked in the conversation | A form of up to 5 questions |
| Who can join | The member and staff | Anyone staff add |
| When it ends | Depends on the bot | An HTML transcript |
Which one to pick
Modmail suits a server with one moderation team and one kind of request, and members who would rather stay in their DMs.
A ticket bot suits a server where requests go to different people: support, billing, staff applications, partnerships. It also suits teams that need the details before they start, or a record of what was said.
Can you use both?
Yes. They're separate bots, and some servers keep modmail for reports and a ticket panel for everything else. Give each kind of request one home and say which in your rules, so members don't open both.
What about ban appeals?
A banned member can't see your server, so they can't use a panel in it. If you take appeals as tickets, put an appeal panel in a small second server and send its invite to the members you ban.
TicketFast is a ticket bot: tickets open from a panel, not from a DM. The setup guide adds it to your server, and the comparison of Discord ticket bots shows how it differs from Ticket Tool and the others.